Daily logbook · Risk & CRM

The Threshold of the Go-Around Decision

Effective cockpit resource management requires treating the go-around as a planned maneuver rather than an admission of failure during a stabilized approach.

By Dmitry ShteynWisconsin, USAOctober 11, 20262 min read
Editorial note

Drafted with AI assistance from a short brief. Reviewed and published by Dmitry Shteyn.

In the cockpit, ego is often the most significant barrier to safety. Pilots frequently view a go-around as a failure to land, when in reality, it is a deliberate transition from an unstable approach to a controlled climb. At Dane County Regional in Madison, a pilot following the ILS to Runway 18 might find themselves slightly high and fast as they cross the final approach fix. The temptation to 'fix it' on the way down is strong, but the moment the aircraft deviates from established parameters—such as being more than one dot off the glide slope or failing to maintain a stabilized airspeed—the decision should already be made.

Aeronautical Decision Making (ADM) relies on predetermined triggers. If you wait until you are flaring over the numbers to decide the approach is bad, you have already exhausted your margin for error. Risk management in the arrival phase means setting hard limits: if the aircraft is not configured, on speed, and on the centerline by 500 feet AGL in visual conditions, the power goes to full and the climb begins. By the time you are wrestling with a gusty crosswind or a ballooning flare, your cognitive load is too high to make a rational assessment. The decision must be binary and calculated well in advance of the runway threshold.

CRM involves communicating these limits clearly, whether flying solo or with a crew. For a student pilot, stating 'if I am not stable by the fence, I am going around' out loud creates a psychological contract. This reduces the hesitation that leads to hard landings or runway excursions. We manage risk by removing the element of surprise from the landing. When a pilot accepts that a landing is an option and the go-around is the default state until touchdown, the pressure to force a bad approach vanishes.

Hazard Warning: Attempting to salvage an unstable approach close to the ground significantly increases the risk of a stall-spin accident or a runway excursion due to excessive kinetic energy.

Educational content, not flight instruction. Consult a certificated flight instructor and current official publications.